At least a half dozen times per week patient’s call with symptoms of a viral upper respiratory tract infection or present to the office for a visit with symptoms and signs of a cold. These illnesses are caused by small viral particles which do not respond to antibiotic treatment. Your body’s defense system attacks these viral particles and over a period of hours to days defeats them. Despite years of ongoing public health announcements and handouts by doctors and nurses and attempts at patient education you find yourself negotiating with strong willed patients who want a “Z Pack” or some other antibiotic which they do not need. “I know my body,” they argue. “My northern or previous physician knew to always give me an antibiotic, why won’t you?”
The answer is quite simple. They do not work to shorten the course, intensity or duration of your illness. They do in fact put you at risk of developing complications of antibiotic use. When your infection requires the use of antibiotics to restore health, it is worth taking these risks. When you do not need the medication it definitely is not. This was confirmed by an article and research presented by E Erik Dubberke, MD of Washington University School of Medicine in Saint Louis, Missouri commenting on Medicare Data about the death rate associated with antibiotic related colitis infections due to Clostridia Difficile. Bacteria normally reside in our large intestine and promote health and digestion. When we prescribe an antibiotic it kills off the healthy and beneficial bacteria as well as the infection related bacteria. This destruction of healthy bacteria creates an environment conducive to “opportunistic “bacteria normally suppressed by the normal flora to invade and take over your gut. The resulting fever, cramping, diarrhea with blood occurs as the intestine become inflamed with colitis. One of the common opportunistic pathogens is Clostridia Difficile.
Dr. Dubberke looked at Medicare data and compared 175,000 patients older than 65 years of age and diagnosed with Clostridia difficile infection and compared them to 1.45 million control patients. He found that those with clostridia difficile infection had a 44% increased risk of death. When comparing admissions to nursing homes for treatment there was an 89% increased risk due to antibiotic related colitis care.
Antibiotics are wonderful when appropriate. They will always carry a risk of a side effect, adverse reaction or complication which is a risk worth taking in the correct setting. It is clearly not worth the risk when your doctor tells you that it will not work.
Filed under: Aging, Antibiotics, Baby Boomers, Best Doctor, Board Certified, Boca Raton, Boca Raton Regional Hospital, Boynton Beach, Broward County, Concierge Medicine, Concierge Physician, Deerfield Beach, Delray Beach, Elderly, Geriatrics, Independent Living, Internal Medicine, Medicare, Miscellaneous, Palm Beach County, Parents, Senior Citizens, West Boca Medical Center | Tagged: Colitis |