My brother in law is a well-respected researcher and biochemist. Thirty years ago he treated his post exercise aching knees with glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate and felt better. Since then he is a fan. Although he is a firm believer in the scientific method and double blind controlled research studies, we could not find any research to support his observations. The discussion then turned to, “it helps me and it doesn’t hurt me so why not?”
In a double blind study sponsored by the National Institute of Health known as GAIT, 1500 or more patients with osteoarthritis and a painful knee were randomized to either receive glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate, each substance individually, Celebrex or placebo for six months. The results showed neither led to reduced pain.
Several other studies were as non-conclusive. In the few studies where pain was reduced the study methods and design were criticized and the results were felt to be questionable as were the conclusions of the researchers. There was nothing positive to say about glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate until a recent study by Martel- Pellitier, Canadian researchers published in Arthritis Care and Research those individuals who took the combination for six years or greater tended to preserve their knee cartilage better than those who did not. While the knee cartilage was maintained there was no difference in pain or complaints of symptoms between the treated and non- treated group. They believe that by preserving knee cartilage over time there may be less necessity for that joint to be replaced eventually.
I am sure over time this will be studied as well. In the meantime glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate seems to have little toxicity and ultimately my brother in law may be on to something positive.
Filed under: Aging, Baby Boomers, Best Doctor, Board Certified, Concierge Medicine, Concierge Physician, Internal Medicine, Miscellaneous, Senior Citizens | Tagged: Arthritis Care and Research, Chondroitin Sulfate, Glucosamine |